1949 · Indian Control Article 370 adopted in India's Constitution
Article 370 (Article 306 in the draft) was negotiated between Gopalaswami Ayyangar and Sheikh Abdullah; talks did not end happily, but India adopted its own draft, enacted by the Constituent Assembly in 1949. As 'temporary provisions', it excluded Article 238, limited Parliament's power to make laws for the State to matters corresponding to the Instrument of Accession (defence, foreign affairs and communications) declared in consultation with the State government, and other matters only with its concurrence; defined the State government as the Maharaja acting on his Council of Ministers under the proclamation of 5 March 1948; and left final decisions to the State's Constituent Assembly. Abdullah, Mirza Afzal Beg, Maulana Masoodi and Moti Ram Bagra were absent when Article 1, placing the State among the Union's Part B States, was adopted. Pampori argues that the article was framed in abnormal conditions with an unelected government, contradicts India's UN commitments, and that the Union could not include a State 40% of whose territory lay across the cease-fire line.
- Law
- Article 370
- Constitution
- India
Jammu and Kashmir · India · target
People
- N. Gopalaswami Ayyangarnegotiator
- Sheikh Mohammad Abdullahnegotiator
- the State's four members in India's Constituent Assembly: Sheikh Abdullah, Mirza Afzal Beg, Maulana Mohammad Sayeed Masoodi and Pandit Moti Ram Bagramembers-absent
- Indialawgiver
Related events
Sources
- Pampori, Kashmir in Chains 1819-1992 (1992), ch. 21. Article 370 in Indian Constitution, p. 356
“Art. 370 (which was Art.306 in the draft) was negotiated between Gopalaswami Aiyanger on one side and Sheikh Mohmad Abdullah on the other.”
- Pampori, Kashmir in Chains 1819-1992 (1992), ch. 21. Article 370 in Indian Constitution, p. 356
“Temporary provisions with respect to the State of Jammu and Kashmir”
- Pampori, Kashmir in Chains 1819-1992 (1992), ch. 21. Article 370 in Indian Constitution, p. 356
“were not present in_the House; that is, the Constituent Assembly of india.”