1 November 1947 · Indian Control Mountbatten and Jinnah discuss a plebiscite formula at Lahore
Nehru did not come, but Mountbatten and Lord Ismay flew to Lahore on 1 November 1947 and discussed Kashmir with Jinnah and Liaquat. Mountbatten proposed that where a ruler did not share the faith of the majority and had not acceded to the corresponding dominion, accession should be decided by an impartial reference to the people. Jinnah thought a plebiscite redundant where majority population was clear, offered Junagadh for Kashmir, would not accept a formula covering Hyderabad, and called the accession the end of a long intrigue brought about by violence. According to Chaudhri Mohammad Ali he proposed that both Governors General order the fighting stopped within 48 hours, Indian troops and tribesmen withdraw together, and the two Governors General administer the State and hold a plebiscite. Mountbatten said as constitutional Governor General he could not decide. Liaquat argued that stopping the tribesmen' buses would have set the Frontier aflame. Pampori calls the talks a calculated move to keep Pakistan's army out.
- Diplomacy
- Plebiscite
- Pakistan
- India
People
- Lord Louis Mountbattennegotiator
- Lord Ismaycompanion
- Muhammad Ali Jinnahnegotiator
- Liaquat Ali Khannegotiator
Sources
- Pampori, Kashmir in Chains 1819-1992 (1992), ch. 18. Action Plans for Annexation of Kashmir, p. 237reports — citing Sardar Patel's Correspondence, Vol. I
“the question of whether the State shoulda finally accede to one or the other of the Dominions should in all cases be decided b”
- Pampori, Kashmir in Chains 1819-1992 (1992), ch. 18. Action Plans for Annexation of Kashmir, p. 237reports — citing Sardar Patel's Correspondence, Vol. I
“this accessi on (of Kashmir) was the end of a long intrigue and that it has been brought about by violence.”
- Pampori, Kashmir in Chains 1819-1992 (1992), ch. 18. Action Plans for Annexation of Kashmir, p. 238reports — citing Ali, Zahoori Pakistan
“On lst November Qaid-i-Azam (Ali Mohmad Jinnah) in his meeting with Mountbatten made following proposa ls”